By Crys
Reviews
B134 posted a comment on Friday 23rd September 2005 3:58am
Is Harry going to realize that the advice Hermoine gave, though somewhat arrogantly phrased, was good? That he was feeling depressed and most of Hermoine's requests when she feels strongly about something are worded as imperatives? That her actual demand was that he find someone to talk to about how he feels, seeking professional attention only if he could not trust those around him or Hermoine herself?
Finally, why do so many writers feel sorry for the werewolves? I'm not sure what making them check in, but not detaining them, is supposed to accomplish. Locking them down during the full moon and killing any that refuse would eliminate (or reduce to near zero) the number of new bites. In a generation it could eliminate the curse in the country. It may be demeaning to current werewolves but it could save countless others from getting the curse or dying in werewolf attacks. At the very least, the punishment for creating another werewolf or killing a human while a werewolf should be death (or life with the dementors, but death seems more humane).
Bill
Rachael posted a comment on Friday 23rd September 2005 4:55am