Content Harry Potter Miscellaneous

Reviews

  • Previous
  • Next

sylvelle posted a comment on Saturday 21st February 2015 9:23pm for 14 - Harry versus Fudge

Shouldn't be TOnks and Harry sorry not right

reader1writer1 posted a comment on Wednesday 8th June 2011 2:44pm for 14 - Harry versus Fudge

Good chapter :)

Cassandra30 posted a comment on Monday 6th June 2011 4:26pm for 14 - Harry versus Fudge

Terrific! I think Harry didn't get enough concessions.

Alex Mcpherson posted a comment on Saturday 28th February 2009 12:19pm for 14 - Harry versus Fudge

nevr mind, wil just embaras meself, going sleep. night.

Crys replied:

'Night.  Hope you feel okay tomorrow morning.

Alex Mcpherson posted a comment on Saturday 28th February 2009 12:17pm for 14 - Harry versus Fudge

- i'm drunk so keep that in mind if this review seems,... stupuid.

gonna read next chapter, like this. and review. so, try an keep next review by me as me trying to durnkenly be fnuny. wink.

bookaholic_au posted a comment on Thursday 19th June 2008 9:04pm for 14 - Harry versus Fudge

So Harry has to convert Tonks aka Miss Havisham to the ranks of the groupies?

dougal74 posted a comment on Tuesday 3rd June 2008 5:29am for 14 - Harry versus Fudge

good chapter

Dragen posted a comment on Friday 9th June 2006 3:42am for 14 - Harry versus Fudge

Great chapter, I like this bit; Fudge tore his eyes from where his assistant had disappeared. "How did you manage to control that pest?"

"Hmm? Oh, I didn't. I asked Peeves to take him away instead. Now, I believe we were threatening each other with bad publicity, weren't we? Though that's something I've had to suffer through from you before."

I don't think Fudge was talking about Percy.

Crys replied:

No, he wasn't.  Harry was, though :)

Kiritsu posted a comment on Wednesday 1st March 2006 1:38am for 14 - Harry versus Fudge

*snickers*
Peeves finally listens to someone
and Fudge is finally getting some of what he deserves
as is Dumbledore
and Snape
*bows to your fanfic-writing awesomeness*

Aurilia posted a comment on Tuesday 28th February 2006 6:43pm for 14 - Harry versus Fudge

Fabtastic.

Lovin' it!

Aaran St Vines posted a comment on Monday 13th February 2006 7:52am for 14 - Harry versus Fudge

Ch.14 - - This was delicious. I have never seen a Harry work with, to a small degree, a Fudge. Great manipulation of him.

I like the good side of Slytherin you are using Tonks to show. They have to have some merit or they'd have been done away with years ago.

Peeves, and especially Peeves with Percy - all of it was GREAT!

TxA_GunFighter posted a comment on Saturday 10th December 2005 8:26am for 14 - Harry versus Fudge

Good one.

gunny

Michapuss posted a comment on Saturday 15th October 2005 8:54pm for 14 - Harry versus Fudge

"How did you manage to control that pest?"



"Hmm? Oh, I didn't. I asked Peeves to take him away instead."



*lol* Has to be one of my favourite lines EVER in a fanfiction.

I only just found this story (I didn't know about this site until 'Sunset over Britain' moved here) and I thought I'd let you know that I'm really enjoying it so far.

Thanks for writing it!

erin_colien posted a comment on Saturday 15th October 2005 5:46pm for 14 - Harry versus Fudge

Really enjoying this story and looking forward to the update.

dogbertcarroll posted a comment on Saturday 15th October 2005 6:27am for 14 - Harry versus Fudge

Excellent work. Great bit with Peeves and Percy. I wonder how far from the school Peeves can travel?

Hoss posted a comment on Friday 14th October 2005 4:31am for 14 - Harry versus Fudge

Great fun and hope fore more updates to come. Thanks

Kat posted a comment on Thursday 13th October 2005 9:55am for 14 - Harry versus Fudge

I just found thist story, and I love it! Keep up the good work, I can't wait to read more!

slashslut posted a comment on Tuesday 11th October 2005 4:15pm for 14 - Harry versus Fudge

*applause, applause, applause* update soon! and often;)

B134 posted a comment on Tuesday 11th October 2005 8:11am for 14 - Harry versus Fudge

Nice chapter.

In Fudge's place I would have tried to turn Harry's willingness to kill deatheaters into a modification of the new werewolf laws. But Fudge is an idiot. He missed his chance by not proposing a modified version of the laws when Harry admitted that some werewolves are dangerous (or dangerous without precautions). Instead set the ball back in Harry's court.

By the way, 'restricting someone for something that happened to them against their will' has a long tradition in medicine / public policy. It's called quarantine. Had they chained typhoid mary to the wall it's likely fewer people would have died (of course she was only one of many carriers). With lycanthropy the situation, as I see it, is clearer than in medicine. Carriers are clearly carriers and there is a limited number of them. They are only contagious one night a month (if I read the fact that Bill did not become a werewolf correctly). Werewolves would only have to be in quarantine one night a month, and the number of new cases of lycanthropy would drop (barring outside efforts to create more werewolves).

Actually, I suspect the werewolf community would support a quarantine measure (but with punishments less harsh than death). We know of no born werewolves, so all the werewolves we know of were attacked by another werewolf which cannot be a pleasent experience. Greyback is a menace so we can ignore his opinion. Remus, the only other werewolf we know, admits he does not always act carefully with regards to his lycanthropy (case in point, his school days). The upside of the quarantine could be improvement of werewolf / general community relations.

By submitting to the quarantine the werewolves show they are concerned for the safety of the community. The limited duration of the quarantine would highlight the fact that they are only dangerous one night a month (and at that time they cannot attack anyone). Couple the quarantine with some additional werewolf rights legislation and you have a package that would increase public safety and improve the lives of the werewolves.


Bill

artdam posted a comment on Sunday 9th October 2005 12:49pm for 14 - Harry versus Fudge

Great story!! Really, really great.
I've just finished what you have written till now and the way you build everything (action and characters) is very realistic to me.
It seems it might end up being H/G which is fine with me and after HBP we saw how loyal she could be to Harry.
Splendid idea with the ghost of Godric, as well.
I realy hope I don't have to wait long to read the next chapter.
Post soon!! I mean now!... please?